Canada’s largest bank is bullish on the economy but not on house prices. RBC’s regulatory filings reveal that it sees home prices dropping slightly by next year. This is if the economy does not face unexpected obstacles. However, the bank warns that they are putting more weight on the downside as the outlook grows bleaker. In a downside scenario, house prices contract by as much as 30% – reversing nearly all gains since 2020. approx.
macroeconomic risk scenarios
Financial institutions should issue forecasts to help plan the amount of preparation required. It’s broken down into 3 scenarios: A base case, which is what would happen if things were going nonstop. Then there are at least two alternative scenarios, including the downside and the upside. Forecasts are a snapshot of the economy at the time, and do not respond to changes. These are used to communicate management expectations if the economy goes off track.
Macroeconomic forecasts like this play a big role, especially in terms of profit. Too bearish? Companies risk less exposure and underperformance of their peers. Too bullish? Lenders may be very exposed to risk, which can mean significant losses. Frankly, these organizations put their money where it belongs.
RBC’s view of Canadian real estate is tilted to the downside
Canada’s largest bank expects prices to fall in the base case scenario, but to bounce back. The CREA standard compound home will show a 3.6% annual decrease by April 2023. The home prices are then expected to show a 4.3% compound annual growth for the following four years. Over the five years ending April 2027, home prices will increase by 14.1%. Only a slight correction followed by an increase in line with long-term growth.
If you don’t measure your child’s birthday in financial quarters, it may just be a bit of an abstraction. Using the benchmark price, the home will drop to $850,600 (- $31,800) by April 2023. The benchmark is then expected to reach $1,006,700 (+ $124,300) by April 2027. That’s still growth Enormous, but it might not seem so to the people who assumed it existed. 30% increments will be forever. However, the downturn in the base case scenario is something to watch.
“While our base case continues to call for positive economic growth, we have increased the severity and likelihood of our negative scenarios,” Graeme Hepworth, chief risk officer at RBC, said in an analyst Q&A on the filing.
The ‘worst case’ for Canadian real estate is a 30% drop in prices.
The bearish scenario for RBC shows a large contraction similar to the 1990s, and a prolonged correction. A standard home could see a 12-month price drop of 30% by April 2023. The average compound annual growth is 4.2% in the following four years. Over the five years ending April 2027, prices will fall by 15.8%.
In dollars, the index drops to $617,700 (- $264,700) by April 2023 and $728,200 (- $154,200) by April 2027. It’s hard to believe that home prices will fall that much but hard to believe they will rise by the same amount. It was also hard to see a 30-year high for inflation and bond yields bucking the 15-year trend.
No recovery over 5 years may sound bad but it isn’t necessarily. After the 1990s crash, home prices failed to bring back inflation in real terms for nearly 20 years. During that period, Canada became one of the best performing economies in the world. Capital sought more productive growth and increased national wealth in a more equitable manner.
The “best case” scenario is another run like the past five years
RBC’s bullish scenario will see a house price boom and higher rates will have no effect. Home prices are expected to increase by 10.9% in April 2023, compared to the previous year. Then the average compound annual growth is 9.5% for the next four years. These numbers may seem small but home prices would have increased by 61.7% in 5 years. This is a similar performance to the past five years, the distribution is completely different.
In this scenario, a standard home would cost $978,600 (+ $96,200) in April 2023. It’s also a staggering $1,406,900 (+ $524,469) by April 2027. The cost of homes across Canada would be roughly the cost of a home in Vancouver today. Of course, incomes will rise, which helps relieve some of the pressure. It is difficult to see this scenario because an upward trend would also mean that interest rates would rise without any hindrance.
Anything is possible but keep in mind that even the risk department of the bank sees a negative bias. They don’t dismiss the last race happening again, but it was a problem. Recent growth has been driven by the same factors that have led to destabilizing inflation. The upside was also not mentioned once during the call, which suggests that it may not be on their mind.
One thing to note: RBC has been outspoken about the impact of higher home prices on the economy. The bank presented several significant negative scenarios. What’s different this time is that the bank is putting a lot of weight on the downside.
RBC hasn’t touched on why their negatives are often so great. However, experts like Hilliard Macbeth Oxford Economics shed some light on the negative outlook through their own research. Just because house prices have to be correct, that doesn’t mean the policy won’t be used to try to prevent it. However, it is not a tool that can be used forever.
Each time the trend is extended, the market is approaching a financial crisis rather than just a price drop.
You may also like