Alberta Utilities Monitoring Agency Closes Company's Offer to 'Refund' Consumer Bills |

Alberta Utilities Monitoring Agency Closes Company’s Offer to ‘Refund’ Consumer Bills |

Alberta’s utilities watchdog has shut down a power transmission company’s plan to give taxpayers a refund, saying the small cash payment proposed by AltaLink would ultimately cost consumers millions more than it returned.

“AltaLink’s proposal will not result in a fair and reasonable tariff although it will provide Alberta electricity customers with some modest relief in their electricity bills,” says the Alberta Utilities Commission’s decision.

“AltaLink’s proposal would immediately require … that customers pay a ‘redemption’ with interest and deductibles over the next 46 years.”

Read more:

AltaLink seeks to recover an additional $350 million over 3 years for Alberta customers

The decision, made Friday, comes after AltaLink — Alberta’s largest electricity transmission company — twice asked the commission for permission to return the money to consumers. AltaLink said the opportunity for a refund stemmed from a slower-than-expected decline in some of the company’s assets.

The story continues below the ad

“Alberta consumers are feeling the pressure of higher energy prices on their electricity bills,” said Gary Hart, president of AltaLink, in a May 2 news release. “Since we won’t be asking for this money for an extended period of time, we think it makes sense to put the $120 million back into the pockets of much-needed Albertans.”

AltaLink’s proposal could have cut the average household bill by $5 per month.

Click to play the video:

Utility costs continue to rise for Calgar

Utility costs continue to rise for Calgar residents – May 2, 2022

But the commission indicated that the return of the money would have been financed by a bank loan, not cash. With interest, deductibles and other fees, the loan would eventually have cost more than $250 million by the end of its term — all of which could have been recovered from consumers.

“There is no compelling reason for future customers to pay higher electricity prices for 46 years given the modest easing in 2022,” the commission wrote.

The story continues below the ad

“AltaLink’s proposal is more suitable as a loan. Refunds do not have to be reimbursed by the person receiving the refund.”

Read more:

The consumer group argues that ATCO’s proposed fine on lined rate requests is insufficient

The commission said the commission calculated that not only would the refund be more than doubled by those who received it, but that AltaLink would likely report a profit of $85 million over the life of the deal. The company’s accounting for the impact of the proposed payback was rejected.

“The review panel found AltaLink’s assumptions … to be unreasonable and designed to achieve a result, which is to demonstrate net current benefits to consumers.”

The committee also said AltaLink’s concerns about the impact of inflation on its customers were “in contrast” to its request for a 10 percent pay rise for key executives.

Click to play the video:

Most Alberta companies ‘extremely concerned’ about energy prices: a survey

Most Alberta companies ‘very concerned’ about energy prices: Survey – April 26, 2022

“While we are disappointed that the Commission has reached this decision, we respect their position,” AltaLink spokesman Scott Schreiner said.

The story continues below the ad

“AltaLink continues to focus on providing solutions to reduce the cost of its service to customers. As part of its commitment to Flat for Five, AltaLink has fulfilled its promise not to raise its prices during this five-year period.”

The Alberta Consumer Coalition appeared before the committee to oppose the proposed recovery of AltaLink.

Read more:

Alberta’s utility bills are expected to remain high throughout 2023

“When you look at all the consequences, all the costs were greater than this short-term benefit,” attorney Jim Wachowitz said.

Wachowich suggested that the refund was an attempt by the company to position itself as helping consumers at a time of high inflation. Wachowich said a better approach would be for AltaLink and other utilities to lower their earnings expectations.

“They didn’t want to do that.”

Commission spokesman Jeff Scotton said the decision was final and represented AltaLink’s last avenue of appeal, with the exception of requesting a private hearing before the Alberta Court of Appeals.

© 2022 Canadian Press

2022-05-17 18:37:38

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *